Skip to main content
Article image
economy6 min read

The battle over 2027 RFS biomass-based diesel volumes begins

The governors of Louisiana and Alabama asked the EPA for a partial waiver of the 2027 RFS, while Farmdoc Daily estimates that required D4 RIN generation will reach 11.55 billion gallons in 2027, above domestic capacity.

Why does the required pace of 963 million RIN gallons per month in 2027 exceed domestic production capacity?

The battle over the 2027 Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS) volumes has already begun. Earlier this week, Louisiana Governor Jeff Landry and Alabama Governor Kay Ivey asked EPA Administrator Lee Zeldin for a partial waiver of the 2027 RFS requirements, in a request they describe as “targeted, prospective, and temporary.”

Landry urged the governors of Texas, Mississippi and Arkansas to join the request. In parallel, biofuel groups and farm organizations quickly urged the EPA to reject the petitions. Scott Irwin's analysis published by Farmdoc Daily, of the University of Illinois, updates the biomass-based diesel (D4) RIN (Renewable Identification Numbers) balance and shows why the record 2027 volumes are at the center of the dispute.

Updated D4 RIN balance sheet

After the small refinery exemptions (SREs) granted by the EPA for 2024 and 2025 and the proposal to reallocate the additional exempted 2025 volume to 2026 and 2027, required net D4 RIN generation falls to 8.82 billion RIN gallons in 2026 and 11.55 billion in 2027. That is 2.17 billion less than the May projection for 2026 and 340 million less for 2027, although the requirement remains 24% above the 2025 level in 2026 and 63% above it in 2027. The result is a sharp step up between the two years: required net generation rises 2.73 billion RIN gallons, or 31%, from 2026 to 2027.

Most of the reduction for 2026 comes from a smaller D6 RIN pull (−960 million) and a larger RIN bank available to draw down (−930 million). Deficits (−240 million) and a lower biomass-based diesel volume (−150 million) also contribute, partly offset by higher export retirements (+300 million).

Monthly pace and actual generation

The required pace is 735 million RIN gallons per month in 2026 and 963 million in 2027. The 2026 figure is 20% below the 916 million pace estimated in May, while the 2027 figure is only 3% below the 991 million projected at that time; it also exceeds every monthly record in history and must be sustained for all 12 months of the year.

Actual generation started 2026 weakly, at 436 million RIN gallons in January and 478 million in February, and recovered gradually: 652 million in March, 709 million in April, 735 million in May and 838 million in June, the highest level since December 2024. It then eased to 793 million in July and 714 million in August, before rebounding to 786 million in September. The January-to-September average was 682 million per month, leaving a cumulative shortfall of about 474 million against the 735 million pace.

To meet 2026 with only the benchmark deficit, generation would have to average 893 million gallons per month from October through December, a level above domestic production capacity and just below the record of 906 million in December 2024. If generation holds at the September level for the rest of the year, the 2026 D4 deficit would be about 600 million RIN gallons, equal to 6.7% of the biomass-based diesel volume, more than double the historical average of 3.1%; every additional gallon of deficit must be repaid in 2027.

Domestic capacity and imports

Operable domestic biomass-based diesel production capacity is estimated at about 878 million RIN gallons per month for 2026 and 2027, calculated from the Energy Information Administration's (EIA) monthly capacity. Even if every biodiesel and renewable diesel plant ran at 100% all year, generation would fall 84 million gallons per month short of the 2027 requirement.

The annual gap, of roughly 1 billion RIN gallons, would have to be filled largely by imports. The balance assumes that biomass-based diesel imports recover from 70 million gallons in 2026 to 1.08 billion gallons in 2027, a level only 14% above 2024 (950 million) and attainable by historical standards. However, conditions have changed: the 45Z credit excludes imported fuel and, starting in 2026, is limited to North American feedstocks; in addition, imports fell to 180 million gallons in 2025 and nearly disappeared in 2026, after the energy market disruptions linked to the war with Iran.

What is at stake

Any relief for 2027 can lower required D4 generation in two ways. A direct cut to the biomass-based diesel volume reduces required generation by one RIN gallon for every gallon cut: a reduction of about 1.01 billion RIN gallons would bring the 2027 requirement down to the level of domestic capacity, and one of 2.73 billion would freeze it at the 2026 level. The second way is a cut to the total renewable fuel volume, which would shrink the conventional gap that D6 ethanol cannot fill and would eliminate the pull of 1.18 billion D6 RIN gallons on D4 in 2027.

The outcome matters directly to soybean oil and other feedstock producers. Producing a physical gallon of biomass-based diesel requires about 8 pounds of feedstock and, with a projected average of 1.54 RINs per gallon in 2027, a cut of 1.01 billion RIN gallons equals about 660 million physical gallons and 5 billion pounds of feedstock; a cut of 2.73 billion would equal about 1.8 billion physical gallons and 14 billion pounds. The American Fuel & Petrochemical Manufacturers (AFPM) estimates that RFS compliance will cost $106 billion in 2026-2027, or between 26 and 35 cents per gallon of gasoline and diesel; the governors of Alabama and Louisiana argue that the 2027 standards would cause “severe economic harm” to their states.

The decisions the EPA makes in the coming months on the waiver petitions, reallocation and SREs will largely determine whether the record 2027 volumes survive. The looming dispute over the half-RIN in Set 3 raises the stakes even higher.