The governors of Louisiana and Alabama, joined by Texas, asked the EPA for a partial waiver of the RFS for 2027, arguing that it makes fuels more expensive. Biofuel producers and farmers urged that it be rejected because it would raise prices and hit demand for corn and soybeans.
Louisiana and Alabama Governors Jeff Landry and Kay Ivey asked the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) for a partial waiver of the Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS) blending obligations for 2027, arguing that the program makes gasoline and diesel more expensive. After filing the request, they urged the governors of Texas, Mississippi and Arkansas to join; so far, the only one to sign on was Texas Governor Greg Abbott.
In a Nov. 9 letter addressed to EPA Administrator Lee Zeldin, Ivey and Landry held that the RFS — which requires a minimum volume of biofuels in the fuels sold in the United States — causes “severe economic harm” by raising prices. “Americans are paying more for gas and diesel because of the Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS). Meanwhile Europe pays zero for the American gas and diesel, and they export it! Time to put American drivers FIRST,” Landry posted on social media. The governors also noted that White House measures — such as deferring the federal excise tax on dyed diesel, pressuring European nations to release 100 million barrels from reserves and rejecting an export ban — helped ease price pressures, but that more is needed.
The petition is limited to 2027 Renewable Volume Obligations (RVO), not those for 2026. “Because the 2026 compliance year is nearly complete, the petitioning states seek relief only for 2027, where a waiver can provide meaningful, prospective relief without disturbing compliance obligations that obligated parties and renewable fuel producers have already planned around for 2026,” they wrote. “We believe waiving the obligations will allow for the economic use of renewable fuel without burdening our citizens with the high prices this program imposes”.
Groups representing biofuel producers and farmers flatly rejected that justification. “Any suggestion that ethanol blending compelled by the RFS is somehow raising gas prices is abjectly absurd and demonstrably false,” said Geoff Cooper, president and CEO of the Renewable Fuels Association (RFA). “Far from delivering ‘relief’ at the pump, a waiver of the 2027 RFS requirements would remove a dependable source of lower-cost, lower-carbon fuel from the marketplace and cause higher gas prices. It would also harm struggling corn and soybean farmers in Alabama, Louisiana, and across the country by undermining demand for their crops. EPA should swiftly and soundly reject these waiver requests.”
The American Soybean Association (ASA) warned that granting the waivers “would strike a major blow to domestic U.S. soybean markets and rural economies”. The association noted that “the national average cost of biofuel blends is lower than that of conventional petroleum-derived fuels” and pointed out that at least one petition “falsely claimed that a waiver would support agriculture and poultry producers, despite the economic benefits that strong renewable fuel demand provides to both industries and rural communities”. “Like all Americans, farmers and ranchers are feeling the impact of prices at the pump and are being forced to make difficult decisions to keep their operations afloat. But make no mistake: undercutting the biofuels program by waiving compliance would result in a giveaway to refineries that are making record profits, while U.S. agriculture would be left holding the bag,” ASA stated. The association stressed that “U.S. oil and gas companies have made a record $160 billion in profits since April, an over 175% increase compared to last year,” while farmers “cannot afford another market loss”.
Scott Irwin, a professor at the University of Illinois, said he was “very surprised” that the two states resorted to the “severe economic harm” argument. “That is a very high bar to meet, and EPA has never approved a previous waiver request based on that justification. By my count, the record is a perfect 0-4,” he said. According to the RFA, since 2008 the EPA has received nearly two dozen waiver petitions from governors and another 14 from refining interests, all rejected for failing to demonstrate the required severe economic harm.
The request comes in a regulatory context that is already sensitive for soybean oil, the main feedstock for biodiesel. On Aug. 31, the EPA exempted 29 refineries from complying with the mandatory requirement to blend biodiesel with diesel and bioethanol with gasoline: 18 received 100% waivers and 11 received 50% waivers, which meant the cancellation of 1.76 billion RINs (Renewable Identification Number) for 2025 compliance. Those exemptions are equivalent to 13.4 billion gallons of gasoline and diesel, 7.5% of the annual supply of both fuels in the United States.
The decision pushed soybean oil quotes on the CME Group lower. On Oct. 13, the EPA announced a review, assuring that the committed volumes would be maintained as they are relocated 100% in later years, but that announcement failed to immediately reverse the bearish trend. The sector also fears that a granted waiver would halt a recovery that was only just beginning: the EPA set the highest renewable volume obligations in the program's history for 2026 and 2027, and soybean crush and biodiesel production were beginning to accelerate.
The debate comes after midterm elections in which fuel affordability was at the center of the agenda and Democrats took control of the House and Senate for next year. The United Steelworkers urged Congress to reform the RFS, arguing that rising compliance costs push prices up and put jobs at risk. “The midterm elections have put affordability front and center, and for working families, few costs are more visible than the price of gas,” said Roy Houseman, the union's legislative director. “Washington needs to recognize how federal fuel policies can affect what Americans pay at the pump and the good-paying jobs that support domestic fuel production.”
Growth Energy warned that rolling back the RFS would undo the Trump administration's “historic work” to boost biofuels. “If EPA were to grant these states the special treatment they're asking for, it would increase fuel prices — not lower them — by reducing the amount of ethanol being blended into America's fuel supply,” said Emily Skor, the group's CEO. For his part, Troy Bredenkamp of the RFA warned that the worst-case scenario would be a granted waiver that set off a chain reaction: “It would have an additive effect over time. Depending on how long the waiver lasts, there could be a significant decline in demand for ethanol and biodiesel.”