Skip to main content
Article image
economy6 min read

Kansas meatpacking towns turn against Trump after ICE raids

An ICE operation detained 104 people in southwest Kansas and hit Dodge City, Garden City and Liberal, whose counties swung more than 20 points toward Democrat Adam Hamilton, the winner of the Senate seat.

Why did the counties hardest hit by the immigration operation punish the ruling party with a swing of more than 20 points?

Federal immigration agents descended on this rural corner of southwest Kansas in late September and detained 104 people, according to the local US Attorney's office. The Hispanic communities of Dodge City, Garden City and Liberal — dominated by meatpacking plants with a mostly immigrant workforce — were hardest hit.

Dodge City gained national prominence in the 19th century as a stop for pioneers heading to the American West, and over time cattle feedlots spread across the open plains. In the 1980s, meatpacking companies began building massive plants: first they employed Vietnamese and Laotian refugees and, later, migrants from Mexico and Central America. Today Dodge City is 67% Hispanic, according to the Census Bureau.

Carlos Rivera was working at the National Beef packing plant on September 22 when he heard from truck drivers that ICE agents had been spotted in town. During the next shift change, some departing employees were detained by agents waiting on the street outside the plant, Rivera said. As news spread, others went back inside, and many spent hours in the cafeteria until the agents left.

Economic impact and local bewilderment

Over the following days, the company's switchboards were jammed with calls from workers reporting absences, Rivera said. Regional cattle and meat industry groups reported disruptions at feedlots, dairies and meat processors, with losses of millions of dollars, and the operation hit the economic activity of the so-called Golden Triangle of Beef.

Local authorities complained that they had been kept in the dark. City Commissioner Rick Sowers was on a morning walk when he noticed flashing lights on several vehicles outside a neighbor's house and masked agents banging on the doors. "I just don't perceive that as an appropriate measure for a document case," he told Reuters, referring to immigration documents.

The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) said ICE "advised cooperative local agencies" before the operation, though it did not specify which ones. But while furious residents criticized officials for not speaking out sooner, Nick Hernandez, Dodge City's first Hispanic city manager, explained that local authorities learned about the operation from social media.

They began calling state and federal legislators for information. Forty-eight hours later, Republican US Senators Jerry Moran and Roger Marshall of Kansas passed along information from DHS that the agents were leaving. "Never during the operation did we find out who was actually in charge," Hernandez said at the meeting.

Even Marshall, long a supporter of Trump's immigration policies, blasted the raids, saying police "were not given advance notice or the level of cooperation we would expect," which caused "mass disruptions to local communities and businesses."

The reaction at the ballot box

Discontent translated into votes on November 3, Election Day. Kansas elected a Democrat to the US Senate for the first time in nearly a century when Adam Hamilton defeated Republican Roger Marshall, who was seeking reelection. The three counties most affected by the ICE raids swung toward Hamilton by more than 20 points on average from the vote share won by Republican President Donald Trump in 2024, according to results compiled by Reuters and USA Today.

Hamilton will be the first Democratic senator to represent the state since 1932 when he takes office in January. In his victory speech, he recalled the story of a woman from Dodge City who told him some parents were too afraid to pick up their children from elementary school. "This was not OK," he said.

The candidate called the raids a "disaster" and said Kansans were "fed up" with Marshall being a "mouthpiece for the president."

The federal response

Asked about this story, DHS — ICE's parent agency — said: "We will continue to enforce our nation's laws and remove illegal aliens from American communities." Lauren Bis, a White House spokesperson, said Trump's "commonsense immigration agenda" had "delivered the most secure border in history."

Trump, after his party's defeat in the midterm elections, has sent mixed signals on immigration policy. He told "60 Minutes" that his deportation campaign may have been "too tough." He then promoted Stephen Miller, architect of his immigration strategy, to chief of staff.

The human cost and the demand for accountability

The human cost of the operation was profound. Karla Flores and her husband Alfredo Arrieta were stopped by immigration agents shortly after leaving a Walmart on the day the operation began; they had planned to shelter at home. Arrieta had crossed illegally into the United States in 2022 and worked as a mechanic in Dodge City; Flores had stayed longer than her tourist visa allowed and worked as a cleaner.

Before being handcuffed, Flores called her brother, who arranged for their three children to be picked up from school and taken to a relative's house. A week later, when their middle son turned 15, the community came together to throw him a party. "We were really impressed by the amount of support from the community," Flores said.

Flores and her husband were deported to Mexico after five weeks in ICE custody and spoke with Reuters by phone. Their two youngest children have joined them, and the eldest, aged 17, is living with Flores' brother. "They're still dealing with the aftermath," Arrieta said of his children. "We got up, we took them to school and a few hours later they're told your mom and dad aren't here anymore."

DHS said that "parents have a choice if they want to be removed with their children or ICE will place the children with a safe person the parent designates."

In the weeks after the raids, New Frontiers, a local nonprofit, delivered hundreds of meals to affected families and helped register voters. Amy Soberanes, a 25-year-old Mexican American business owner, said the community believed itself "untouchable" because of the meatpacking plants and their dependence on immigrant workers, and that she had never seen people so politically mobilized. "Our community wants people to be held responsible for what happened," she concluded.