Skip to main content
Article image
economy8 min read

Getting into farming is hard, but for many, retiring is harder

The average age of farmers in the U.S. is 58, and an estimated 50 million acres in the Midwest will change hands before the end of the decade. Specialists urge families to plan succession years in advance.

Why do specialists recommend planning succession years in advance and starting with the family rather than with the paperwork?

PANORA, Iowa — When the sun comes up over the tree-lined pasture at Early Morning Harvest, Earl Hafner, 79, has already been working for hours. He spreads buckets of a white powder on the grass where his cattle graze, and about three dozen cows come down the hill to devour the morning snack, a byproduct of the organic grains Hafner grew for decades.

“It’s like candy to a cow,” he said. “I mean, they love it.”

His son Jeff Hafner now owns the farm and handles daily operations, but Earl still helps out. Jeff jokes that his father retired to an eight-hour day.

“I don’t sleep well unless I work hard during the day,” Earl said.

Although he is still up early to feed the cattle and then climbs into the combine, Earl has gradually stepped back from managing the farm and let Jeff take the lead. That change took years, and Earl much prefers it to the alternative.

“I see so many other farms that just get sold to the highest bidder, and with that go all the memories and the hard work,” he said. “If you do it right, the next generation will inherit something and, hopefully, will see that, if they manage it, it’s a good asset.”

A retirement that goes beyond the business

The transition the Hafners went through is one that many farm families postpone or ignore. Retiring from a career in agriculture doesn’t just mean letting go of the land and a business: it also means giving up an identity.

“We know there’s going to be conflict, and that paralyzes people with fear,” said Wesley Tucker, of the University of Missouri Extension. “They are afraid of making a mistake and doing something wrong, so they choose to do nothing, and that’s the worst thing they can do.”

Tucker’s official title is agricultural business specialist, but he said a more accurate title would be “family dynamics specialist,” since his goal is to help families “work through these sensitive issues and have some of those hard conversations.”

Tucker offers workshops and one-on-one counseling to farmers handing their business to the next generation, and in recent years he has received more requests for help.

“Farm succession is a huge need in rural America, but it’s a topic a lot of people choose to ignore,” he said. “They don’t want to deal with it, partly because no one wants to think about their own death.”

Tucker warned that when succession is done halfway, or not at all, the result can be losing the farm.

“It’s common for people to say, ‘Well, my kids get along pretty well. I think they’ll work it out,’” Tucker said. “My advice every time I hear that is: why don’t you go get the ‘for sale’ sign now? Because that’s probably what’s going to happen.”

The average age of farmers in the United States is 58, and it keeps rising. As those producers retire or die, at least 50 million acres of Midwest farmland are expected to change hands before the end of the decade — an area similar to that of Nebraska.

Planning the vision before the paperwork

Faced with this historic transition, farm organizations are putting additional emphasis on helping families through the process. Martha McFarland, farmland transition manager at the nonprofit Practical Farmers of Iowa, said nearly 40% of Iowa’s farmland is owned by someone 75 or older.

McFarland noted that a common mistake is going to the lawyer as a first step, before having the hard conversations as a family.

“If you were going to remodel your kitchen, you wouldn’t bring in a contractor and say, ‘Hey, what color should I paint the walls?’” McFarland said. “More than likely, by the time you bring in a contractor, you already have the vision and you know what you want to do.”

That’s why she advises her clients to find that vision first, starting by thinking about the legacy they want to leave, and to set goals for the family, the farm and the land long before starting the paperwork.

Succession planning is more than a financial process and can take years of mentoring to prepare an heir.

“Succession planning starts when you give your kids their first set of chores,” Tucker said.

He recommends that families give the younger generation more responsibility as they grow, teaching them management and leadership skills before handing over the reins entirely.

“I think that’s what scares the older generation so much. They see it as all or nothing,” Tucker said. “They see it as: ‘Well, today I’m the farmer and tomorrow you are.’ That’s not how it works, or at least it shouldn’t work. Are you preparing them to be your successor, or are you treating your kids like hired hands?”

Training the next generation

Preparing the next generation is an urgent matter, said Wyatt Fraas, who works with new farmers at the Center for Rural Affairs, a nonprofit based in Nebraska.

“We’re in the middle of the baby boomer retirement surge among farmers, just like in every other occupation in the country,” Fraas said. “So we need new farmers coming in as replacements, as partners.”

The Center for Rural Affairs offers financial literacy and business planning resources for beginning farmers. “Farms and ranches are often the economic engine of rural areas,” Fraas said.

At Kansas State University, Ashlee Westerhold, director of the Office of Farm and Ranch Transition, teaches “Returning to the Farm” to juniors and seniors.

“We have students fill out financial statements and understand: what would my role be if I came back? Can I make money farming? How much do I need to earn to support my family? Is it possible?” Westerhold said.

Farming is a low-margin business. Farm kids who want to return often need to pay their own way; Westerhold recommends exploring whether they can diversify the family business to generate more income.

“A lot of people don’t know the ins and outs of the family business, especially in farming and ranching, until they own it,” she explained. “It can be a really hard place when you haven’t seen the numbers until you’re 55.”

Fraas stressed that the older generation can’t afford to simply hand over the farm, because their retirement is tied to the assets of the business and the land.

“Their savings, their income or their investment is tied up in the land, the facilities and the business,” he said.

Selling the business and the land to a successor can give the farmer income for retirement, but it is a challenge for social and emotional reasons: farmers often live on the land they farm, which makes it hard for the older generation to let go.

“You’re asking a farmer whose whole identity is wrapped up in farming to stop being a farmer. How do we figure that out?” McFarland said. “How do we help someone feel that they are passing along that legacy, that vision for the land, that care for the land, in a way that, at the end of the day, they also feel they have a purpose?”

The Hafner case: mentoring and constant communication

As a young man, Jeff Hafner left the farm, went to college and spent time in the military. When he came back home, his father encouraged him to make certain elements of the farm his own and taught him the different aspects of the operation.

“I’m blessed that he wanted to be a mentor rather than having the ‘I’m not going to let it go’ attitude,” Jeff Hafner said.

Over time, the Hafners put the farm’s assets — the equipment, the land and the various business entities — in Jeff’s name. In 2011, they launched Early Morning Harvest, their organic products brand — flour, grits and cornmeal — made from the grains grown on the farm. It was a new chapter for the business and an opportunity for Jeff to lead.

“You can’t have two bosses,” Earl recalled telling Jeff at the time. “So I told him I would help, but I didn’t want to be an owner.”

Today, Jeff manages every aspect of the farm: the flour mill, the crops, a greenhouse and the farm store. Earl provides support.

“He does whatever he wants and I put out fires,” Jeff said.

Both stress that regular and honest communication has been the key to their successful transfer — a need that still exists.

“Between him and me, officially on the books, yes, it’s probably done. But between him and me, personally, it’ll never be done,” Jeff said.

Now, Jeff has begun planning his own succession. This year, demand for Early Morning Harvest products was so high that Jeff started buying additional grains from other organic farmers to make them. He said finding a way to sustain this new market will be his legacy.