Democrats won the House and Senate with victories in farm states, redefining the drafting of the next farm bill and trade policy. The turnover in the agriculture committees includes departures of leaders from both parties and a contest for the Democratic leadership.
Democrats won control of the House of Representatives and the Senate in Tuesday's midterm elections, driven by victories in farm states that Republicans considered safe. The result redefines who will write the next farm bill and trade policy, in a context of record diesel prices, rising beef prices, tariffs and a farm bill that never arrived.
In the House, nearly half a dozen seats held by Republicans on the Agriculture Committee changed hands, while the future of a handful of other Republican committee members remained undecided. In the Senate, Democrat Adam Hamilton defeated Republican Roger Marshall in Kansas, meaning the state will send a Democrat to the upper chamber for the first time in nearly a century. In Iowa, Democrat Josh Turek defeated Republican Rep. Ashley Hinson in the race to succeed retiring Sen. Joni Ernst, and Democrat Sarah Trone Garriott was projected to win the seat of Rep. Zach Nunn, another member of the House Agriculture Committee. Mississippi Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith, also on the committee, was locked in a race too close to call, while Democrat Rob Sand was projected as Iowa's next governor.
The turnover was already shaping up before the vote as one of the largest in years: at least nine House Agriculture Committee members and five Senate members would leave Congress at the end of the 119th session. Among the confirmed departures are Democrat Angie Craig (Minnesota), who lost her Senate primary; Republicans Randy Feenstra (Iowa) and Dusty Johnson (South Dakota), defeated in their gubernatorial primaries; and Republicans Don Bacon (Nebraska) and Dan Newhouse (Washington), who are retiring. Also leaving the House are Shri Thanedar (Michigan), who lost his primary, and Republicans Barry Moore (Alabama) and John Rose (Tennessee), who are seeking other offices. In the Senate, Republicans Joni Ernst (Iowa) and Mitch McConnell (Kentucky) and Democrats Dick Durbin (Illinois) and Tina Smith (Minnesota) are retiring, while Tommy Tuberville (Alabama) and Amy Klobuchar (Minnesota) are running for governor.
Craig's departure leaves the Democratic leadership of the House Agriculture Committee vacant. Rep. Shontel Brown (Ohio), currently the committee's vice ranking member, formalized her candidacy on a platform of affordability, accountability and coalition-building, and highlighted her knowledge of the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) and of farm programs. Rep. Jim Costa (California) also launched his bid and sent a letter to House Democrats asking for support, with emphasis on his experience on the committee and on rebuilding bipartisan backing for the farm bill, in addition to demanding that the Trump administration "answer for its disastrous attempt to reorganize the USDA."
One of the most immediate questions after the power shift is whether the new majority will change the way Democrats negotiate the farm bill. Republican Sen. Chuck Grassley (Iowa) broke with the notion that Republicans would not consider a two-year extension of the SNAP cost-share to win Democratic support. "I hate to talk about compromising on getting fraud out of food stamps, but there may be some sort of compromise. We'll have to negotiate with the Democrats to get 60 votes and get the bill out," he said Tuesday. "It'll take some compromise, perhaps on this food stamp issue." Grassley called a two-year, $18 billion cost-share arrangement "irresponsible," but added: "On the other hand, we have a chance of getting E15 if we get this farm bill passed, and that's $14 billion more in the pockets of farmers, so that's what I have to analyze." Republican Sen. John Boozman (Arkansas) had called the one-year SNAP cost-share delay Republicans' and the White House's final offer.
Despite those moves, consultant Mary Kay Thatcher was skeptical about the possibility of passing a full farm bill before the end of the year. "We are going to have a farm bill extension. I have no doubt that will happen," she predicted.
Farm groups are preparing to work with the new leadership and with a large class of freshman lawmakers in the 120th Congress. "When those leadership positions are identified, we're going to be in the room working with whoever is in leadership, making sure they understand the needs of agriculture and rural America," said John Newton, vice president of public policy and economic analysis at the American Farm Bureau Federation. "We have members coming in from across the country in February. So our goal and our preparation is to make sure that, when the 120th Congress begins, Farm Bureau is in the room."
On the Democratic side, former Sen. Heidi Heitkamp (North Dakota) called the result "a reset button for bipartisanship as it relates to the farm bill and agricultural policy," and added: "My hope is that we get back to farm policy being bipartisan, and almost nonpartisan." Former House Agriculture Committee Chairman Collin Peterson warned that "you can't run farm policy on just one party. If you do that, you're going to end up going back and forth and farmers are going to get whipsawed." "They need to get back to doing things the way they used to do them, and maybe this election was enough to get their attention and make them do that," he added.