A study by agri benchmark finds that Brazilian soybean farms cost $416 per acre versus $616 in the U.S. between 2020 and 2024; the gap is explained by land, not inputs: Brazil spent more on fertilizer and pesticides.
A study by the agri benchmark network compared seed, fertilizer and pesticide costs on nine typical soybean farms in Brazil and the United States between 2020 and 2024, and concluded that the cost advantage of Brazilian farms is structural and does not come from inputs. Brazilian farms had an average total cost of $416 per acre, versus $616 on U.S. farms.
The analysis is published at a time of growing concern about the competitiveness of U.S. soybeans: in the September 2026 Purdue University and CME Group Ag Economy Barometer, 80% of producers said they were concerned or very concerned about the competitiveness of U.S. soybeans relative to Brazil, and a record 52% cited high input costs as their main concern. Since the U.S.–China trade dispute began in 2018, China has increasingly turned to Brazil, and in the 2025/26 crop year Brazil exported a record 115 million metric tons of soybeans, 61% of world trade, versus 41.4 million metric tons from the United States.
The sample includes four Brazilian farms (three in Mato Grosso and one in Paraná) and five U.S. farms (two in Indiana and one each in Iowa, North Dakota and Ohio). The data cover 2020–2024, except for Mato Grosso 3 (2020–2023) and Ohio (2021–2024), a period that spans the COVID-19 pandemic and the surge in input prices after Russia's invasion of Ukraine. Yields were relatively similar: 51 bushels per acre in Brazil versus 55 in the United States, a U.S. average dragged down by the North Dakota farm, which averaged 37 bushels per acre.
Most of the gap in total cost comes from overhead costs, above all land, which accounted for about 40% of costs in the United States and between 19% and 30% in Brazil. Direct costs show the opposite pattern: about half of Brazilian costs (47% to 57%) versus roughly one-third of U.S. costs (30% to 35%). On average, direct costs were similar: $218 per acre in Brazil and $200 in the United States, but that similarity hides important differences in their composition.
Brazilian farms spent more on fertilizer than U.S. farms in every year analyzed: $85 per acre versus $57 on average. The difference reflects both the quantities applied and what is paid for them: the acidic, nutrient-poor soils of the Cerrado require large volumes of fertilizer and lime. Brazil is the world's largest fertilizer importer: it imports about 72% of the phosphate and 96% of the potash it consumes, compared with 16% and 95% in the United States, and those inputs must be trucked to the main producing regions of the Center-West. In the sample, the gap comes mostly from phosphorus, where Brazilian farms spent about twice as much as U.S. farms.
Because fertilizer is traded in dollars, Brazilian producers pay more in local currency whenever the real weakens. Russia's invasion of Ukraine sent fertilizer prices soaring in 2022: in the United States the cost peaked at $78 per acre that year, double the 2020 level, while in Brazil the peak came a year later, in 2023, at $150 per acre, nearly triple the 2020 level, because fertilizer bought at the 2022 price peak likely fed into Brazil's 2022/23 crop. By 2024, costs had eased to $83 per acre in Brazil and $61 in the United States.
Pesticide costs followed a similar path. Brazilian farms spent more in every year analyzed, $81 per acre versus $56 on average, with a peak of $123 in Brazil in 2023. The mix also differs: the U.S. farms in the sample report only herbicide costs for soybeans, although nationally about one-fifth of U.S. soybean acreage receives a fungicide and one-fifth an insecticide. Brazilian farms spend more on fungicides and insecticides, a reflection of heavier insect and disease pressure in a climate without hard winter freezes and with high humidity during the growing season. As with fertilizer, many of these chemicals are imported and must travel long distances from the ports to the Center-West.
Seed is the only input on which U.S. farms spend more than Brazilian farms: $66 per acre on average versus $43, in every year of the period. Both countries plant genetically modified seed almost exclusively, but not the same seed: the average U.S. seed carries more stacked traits, and its price rises with each added trait. Brazil also produces its own seed, so its costs are less exposed to import prices quoted in dollars.
The rules on saving seed also differ. U.S. producers cannot legally save and replant patented genetically modified seed (Bowman v. Monsanto, 2013), while Brazilian producers, mostly smaller, can save their own and pay royalties on patented traits. The gap, however, is narrowing: seed costs in Brazil doubled between 2020 and 2024, from $27 to $58, while in the United States they rose 13%, from $62 to $70.
Among the farms in the sample, Brazil's lower total cost does not come from inputs: Brazilian farms paid less for seed but more for fertilizer and pesticides in every year analyzed, and their direct costs averaged $218 per acre, versus $200 in the United States. Most of the difference comes from overhead costs: $97 per acre in Brazil versus $251 in the United States.
Brazil's reliance on imported inputs also makes its advantage more vulnerable to price swings. In 2023, when input costs in Brazil peaked, the gap in total cost per acre narrowed to $71; in every other year the difference exceeded $200. The message for U.S. producers is twofold: trimming input spending alone is unlikely to eliminate Brazil's advantage, because most of the difference is structural and rooted in land, but that advantage depends heavily on cheaper land and imported inputs, and it erodes quickly when those prices rise.